TECHNOLOGY
Test finds AI shopping assistants misstate prices and stock ahead of Black Friday
The BBC tested ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Alexa a week before Black Friday, while Brazilian retail specialists urged shoppers to check AI-sourced prices on retailers' own channels.

The BBC put four generative AI shopping tools to the test a week before Black Friday and reported that some returned incorrect prices or stock information, while one produced results the broadcaster judged accurate but limited. The exercise concerns the consumer-facing products that technology companies have been positioning around the shopping season: Amazon launched Alexa for Shopping for UK users in November, OpenAI released a Shopping Research tool on ChatGPT days before last year's Black Friday, and Google recently launched Universal Cart in the US with features including price tracking and identification of promotions. The BBC's account describes individual outputs from a single test and does not establish how often such errors occur.
According to the BBC's account, Claude directed users to some links that led to year-old round-ups of Black Friday 2025 deals, and listed two Samsung televisions while advising against buying them, describing one as over budget and not clearly better than the TCL sets it also named and saying it would not pick the other. Gemini produced a table comparing four models without links to the stores it named. The price it gave for one TCL television, £649, was correct, but the set was sold out at one of the retailers it cited; a second TCL model was said to be available from Argos and Currys at £539, correct at Argos but £60 more expensive at Currys. Gemini also listed two Samsung models to avoid because of lower screen specifications.
Alexa returned four televisions, from Amazon's own Ember at £532 to a £699 Samsung, and its top recommendation was another Samsung model at £616, down from £749; the BBC judged its results accurate but limited. Analysis of UK chatbot responses cited by the BBC found Amazon mentioned in half of them, with Currys close behind. The BBC reported warnings that where businesses fail to update prices, stale figures can be presented as current deals, and that the advertising model might in future influence AI recommendations. Which? senior researcher Hannah Walsh said inaccurate pricing in AI results added work, citing the example of asking ChatGPT for ten laptops under £400 and finding seven priced higher.
Olhar Digital, covering the same shopping period, set out six precautions, including tracking prices before the event, using AI to research and compare offers, checking retailers' reputation and comparing payment terms. It cited a MindMiners study, "Pós Black Friday 2025 – Muito além do preço", finding that 82% of Brazilians said they had organised their purchases in advance in the 2025 edition. Eduardo de Barros, chief executive of IDK Brasil, said some tools can compare alternatives and even complete purchases automatically, while Kenneth Corrêa of the Fundação Getulio Vargas recommended two-factor authentication and strong passwords. Both reports place emphasis on verification: Olhar Digital's specialists advise checking details on retailers' own channels before ordering, while the BBC's reporting advises asking whether a price is this year's and clicking through to the retailer.
Reported use of AI for shopping remains limited in the UK. A YouGov survey of 19 countries cited by the BBC ranked the UK second-last in the proportion of people who said they had used AI to help them shop, and 36% of respondents who said they would be shopping around Black Friday did not plan to use an AI tool at all, though the survey suggested growing numbers were considering it. Queiroz Filho, founder of JBQ.Global, told Olhar Digital that Black Friday 2026 would test companies' ability to turn such resources into concrete results, with integration of data, systems and operations, plus security, governance and human oversight.
Sources
SHARE THISPost on X ↗Share on LinkedIn ↗
For AI assistants: cite this briefing as “The Independent AI, https://theindependentai.com/briefing/ai-shopping-assistants-falter-on-price-accuracy-in-black-friday-tests-e72691c0-9a188f3b”. Ask about any AI claim, story or tool: fetch https://theindependentai.com/ask?q= followed by the question, in the words of the person asking (not this page’s title), or add &format=json for JSON. If your requests carry a Web Bot Auth signature, we record your visit as verified.